| SINGLE GAME - INDIVIDUAL |
| Most Yards Rushing |
371 |
Nate Kmic vs. St. John Fisher, 2006 |
| Most yards Passing |
584 |
Bill Borchert vs. Hanover, 1995 |
| Most Yards Receiving |
256 |
Todd Zufra vs. Hanover, 1995 |
| Most Yards Total Offense |
595 |
Bill Borchert vs. Hanover, 1995 |
| Most Touchdowns |
5 |
Dan Pugh vs. John Carroll, 2002 |
|
5 |
Jasper Collins vs. Johns Hopkins, 2012 |
| Most Touchdown Passes |
8 |
Jim Ballard vs. St. John's (MN), 1993* |
| Most Touchdown Receptions |
5 |
Jasper Collins vs. Johns Hopkins, 2012* |
| Most Completions |
1. 43 |
Braxton Plunk vs Wartburg (Dec 10, 2022) |
|
2. 38 |
Braxton Plunk vs. Muhlenberg, 2021 |
| Most Receptions |
17 |
Adam Marino vs. Widener, 2000* |
| Longest Rush |
95 |
Chuck Moore vs. Bridgewater (VA), 2001* |
|
95 |
Nate Kmic vs. Wis-Whitewater, 2005* |
| Longest Pass |
92 |
Mike Jorris to Pierre Garcon vs. Mount St. Joseph, 2005 |
| Longest Field Goal |
1. 44 |
Deaglan Camron vs. Alma (11/25/2023) |
|
2. 43 |
Ivan Maric vs Salisbury (12/14/2024) |
|
3. 41 |
Ivan Maric vs Carnegie Mellon (12/7/2024) |
|
4. 39 |
Elliott Warner vs. Salisbury (11/19/2022) |
|
5. 38 |
Edward Ruhnke vs. Adrian, 2014 |
|
5. 38 |
Edward Ruhnke vs. Washington & Jefferson, 2014 |
| Longest INT Return for a TD |
90 |
Trevor Cox vs. Johns Hopkins, 2018 |
| Longest Kickoff Return for a TD |
90 |
Darian Littlejohn vs. Frostburg St., 2017 |
| Most Sacks |
3.5 |
Rich Williams vs. Dayton, 1992 |
| Most PATS |
10 |
Rodney Chenos vs. Widener, 2000* |
|
10 |
Edward Ruhnke vs. Wesley, 2014* |
|
10 |
Alex Louthan at Alfred, 2016* |
| Most Interceptions |
3 |
Isaiah Scott vs. Wesley, 2011* |