Player

 Pos.

 Year (s)

 Team

 Grace Heath

 OF

 2021
 2022

 Third Team
 First Team

 Lindsey Royer

 P

 2008

 Third Team

 Erin Duignan

 OF

 2006

 Second Team

 Sara Tharp

 UT

 2002

 First Team

 Adrianne Cole

 SS

 2000
 1999
 1998

 Second Team
 First Team
 Second Team

 Jenny Grower

 3B

 1991

 First Team

 Laura Stickle

 OF

 1988

 Second Team

 Katie Lepp

 2B

 1988

 Honorable Mention